The Tisas gets high marks for being all forged while the Rock Island is cast . Others require a lot of work to get them shooting reliably, and some never do.if(typeof ez_ad_units!='undefined'){ez_ad_units.push([[300,250],'americangunfacts_com-leader-3','ezslot_10',181,'0','0'])};__ez_fad_position('div-gpt-ad-americangunfacts_com-leader-3-0');if(typeof ez_ad_units!='undefined'){ez_ad_units.push([[300,250],'americangunfacts_com-leader-3','ezslot_11',181,'0','1'])};__ez_fad_position('div-gpt-ad-americangunfacts_com-leader-3-0_1');.leader-3-multi-181{border:none!important;display:block!important;float:none!important;line-height:0;margin-bottom:7px!important;margin-left:auto!important;margin-right:auto!important;margin-top:7px!important;max-width:100%!important;min-height:250px;padding:0;text-align:center!important}, For us, the bigger issue is that 2003 date. By Steel frame with a Parkerized finish. By this time its obvious that I rely on Glocks. Armscor Rock Island M1911-A1 ROCK Ultra FS 10mm 51991 vs Smith & Wesson M&P 10MM M2.0 Thumb Safety Optics Ready Slide 10mm 13388 Compare Recent coupons (10) $40 off $275+ WINTER40 Expiration date Unknown Store Brownells Report $30 off $215+ 30off215 Expiration date Unknown Store Brownells Report $150 Off $1,000+ FEB150 Of course it is a range toy. The double-diamond grips honor the original M1911 checkered walnut stocks, but feature Springfield Armorys cross-cannon logo that harkens back to the federal armory located in Springfield, Massachusetts, which closed in 1968. Bonus: Hickok45 video review - He compares them with $1k 1911 but I'm more interested in which is best between these and the other cheap 1911s. Bottom Line:An affordable entry to owning a more-than-functional M1911A1 that shoots well. Colt 1911A1s and subsequent models have demonstrated a higher demand and resale value than other brands over time. Compare. Had a few miss feeds in the first 100 or so. They may be finicky with certain loads, may need minimal tuning for optimal reliability, and small internal parts may or may not excessively wear or break after 500 or 5000 rounds. It was witnessed that he used an M1911 to shoot a Japanese sniper at 80 yards, demonstrating its accuracy potential with one-hand shooting. Sds Imports 1911A1 Service 45 45Acp . After youve settled on form, then there are about as many finishes and accessories as you could ever want, so its more than possible to make a 1911 truly yours. Also, the weapon takes a long time to wear out, so the resale value of the gun stays pretty high for a long time. They should give you a pretty good representation of how a proper functioning 1911 should be. Gee wiz David, if Delta Force, found the 1911 a good, and reliable pistol, I would have to tell you you are simply dead wrong. You are correct that DA/SA are more difficult to shoot well. My first 1911 was a Kimber Stainless II .45. It takes more training to be good with the 1911 but thats OK. As far as the problems with out-of the box 1911s not feeding, it is usually due to trying to load hollow point ammo. Its just worth your money. Except the aluminum frame ones thats just blasphemy. If youre making a movie and need a firearm sponsor to go along with the flashy tactical moves, then Kimber has you absolutely covered. Its not the best, but its good. Additionally, this Armscor pistol lacks the arched mainspring housing, and it wears smooth wooden grips rather than diamond-checkered walnut or brown plastic stocks found on originals. Free shipping. SDS Imports is an importer of firearms from around the Globe to serve the American Market. Springfield Armory is a US company and buying their products supports them. After the foundation of the International Practical Shooting Confederation (IPSC) in 1976, the 1911 rose to prominence as the best platform to use for building competition handguns. As opposed to that, SDS isnt even nearly as popular as Rock Island. The SR 1911 has a nice stainless finish, Novak windage adjustable sights, adjustable trigger, the mags are sturdy (one is 8 round). In 2015, Mann began contributing to Field & Stream to cover guns, ammunition, ballistics, and hunting. All Deals; Today; Categories . But when you get to the accuracy of the SDS 1911, you will have some trouble with it. Where this pistol is lacking is in the inclusion of many of the upgrades gunsmiths like Bill Wilson made popular. Caliber choices include 45acp, 10mm, 40 S&W and 9mm. Caliber.45 ACP. Other than that, Rock Island is a better option in all aspects. The most common complaints are the odd failure to feed or return to battery within the first few. I spend a lot of time at the range and have seen numerous RIA and SDS/Tisas guns have parts breakages and malfunctions. Fixed on top of the slide. While, One of the biggest pros of the 1911 is the. What this means is that you will have to, The sights on the RIA GI 1911 are also minimalistic, which is to be expected on any G.I style of 1911. Most modern replicas of the M1911A1 will run you between $900 and $1000 for a newly made pistol. Its better in build quality and almost every aspect of a classic 1911. A brand new, Rock Island Armory currently produces a handful of, All RIA 1911s are built out of 4140 chromoly steel. Looking at Mil-Spec WWII style and the Turkish Tisas and The Phillipines Rock Islands seem to be best options. American soldiers fighting close-quarters battles have often reached for an M1911 and the .45 has proved to be a reliable performance benchmark. While this finish is admittedly rather dull and crude looking, it actually provides better protection against rust and moisture than standard bluing does. The extended beavertail is tastefully modern with protection from being bitten by the spur hammer, which even has a subtly reduced profile. Now, if your Norinco has some major flaw, youre on your own to fix it. Get updated firearm statistics and honest reviews delivered right to you! Learn More. The pistol features a parkerized finish, properly designed checkered plastic grips, an arched mainspring housing, and the original spur hammer. It shares lineage with the original M1911 and M1911A1, and this can be seen in details. Regarding the build quality, I will always keep the Rock Island 1911. The one I dont shoot is a first gen Delta Elite in bright stainless. The Taurus might not offer complete parts interchangeability. Also, gun control is excellent, thanks to the build quality of the gun. 23 sold. It went bang everytime i pulled the trigger.and the trigger its amazing.I also have a couple colts. Rock Island is the name of an old, US government arsenal that made, among other things, great 1911 pistols. I disagree on your analysis of Rock Island Armory products. Kimber Rapide purchased in November, 2021 and has 600 rounds of various makes of FMJ and HP ammo. But a custom 1911 is not just about appearance and modernization, its about perfection. or Best Offer. The SCAR 15P is chambered for 5.56 NATO and, with its 7.5-inch barrel, is the most compact SCAR to date. Zurich Shield Vs. Ammo Designed for the Way You Shoot. This article by Alex Joseph originally appeared at Gun News Daily in 2019. Yes, its decent for sure, but when you bring a Rock Island into the comparison, I think it doesnt even stand a chance. Which 1911 is right for you? Ruger's multi-role small frame autoloading rifle - Sear - combines AR-10 power with AR-15 Portability. . When I first got it the sear spring wasnt properly tuned and the grip safety just flopped around. Pistol ordered is 1911 A2 FS HC (14 rounds) I understand the 1911 model,,, FS is Full size,,,,, HC is high capacity but I didn't fathom the A2 Vs A1 designation difference. I've been asked about the differences between these two 1911 pistols. Does all that money just buy bells and whistles, or is there really something to dropping a few bills on a 1911? Accuracy on one was very good, the other moderate. I would (and have) purchase a Rock Island. Conversely, with a Glock 17, I have two out of the box with no cleaning, no lube, and no mods whatsoever. Will it last a lifetime? The sights are small and hard to see. Learn about the guns and know how they work they arent that hard to understand. To some extent that belief still exists but its not necessarily the case. No such luck4 rounds in, the slide jammed in the exact same way, and continued to do so every 4-5 rounds. Type: Recoil operated, semiautomaticCartridge: .45 ACPCapacity: 7+1 rds.Barrel: 5 in.Overall Length: 8.6 in.Weight: 2 lbs., 7 oz.Grips: Cocobolo, double-diamond checkeredFinish: Parkerized (steel)Sights: 3 white dot; fixed blade (front); drift-adj. The Creedmoor is the hottest cartridge on the planet. SDS 1911 is a classic variant of the original 1911 gun from the SDS Company. But theres another end of the spectrum. From the GI Standard FS 9mm at $522 to the GI Standard FS Nickel in both the 45ACP and 38SUPER at $814, it provides a range of prices for any type of shooter. While its not an exact replica of the M1911A1, the spirit of the original is there. Find an authorized Rock Island Armory dealer near you. Periodically carry as my EDC. View Deal . Costa Green Mirror Vs. Blue Mirror For Fishing (2023). The slide serrations are akin to the originals, and in other places the aptly named A2 offers modern touches that include an extended, serrated thumb safety lever, a functionally-minded lowered and flared ejection port. The SDS (Tisas) Duty has ~ 150 rounds fired and the RIA Tactical II has exactly 50 rounds fired (this was my first time firing it). If you purchase a firearm using the links in this story, we may earn commission. Generally, price shouldnt concern you too much when getting a handgun. Why is Leave a Comment Cancel Reply. Youll spend $2500 plus to get there, but buyer beware. if a jughead like me can replace stuff, anybody can. The SDS had fixed sights, so I installed a set of LPA adjustable FO sights on it. kygunco.com . Second Media Inc., 30800 Telegraph Rd, Suite 1921, Bingham Farms, MI 48025 USA. Come join the discussion about optics, gunsmithing, styles, reviews, accessories, classifieds, and more! Usually, people dont want to sell the Rock Island 1911 that much because they are so good in quality. Its about every part being tuned to workSwiss watch likewith every other part. I have a Rock Island Officer size. On the low end, the GI Series of pistols generally runs less expensive in MSRP than the Rock Series. For the most part, the reviews on most import 1911s reveal a few common threads. While it might leave the history buff snorting in contempt, the alternate-history approach is clever and makes for an excellent pistol that most traditionalists should enjoy. Out of all the different variations, Rock Island 1911 is the closest you will get to the timeless M1911. "Government exists to protect us from each other. All of them are great the first three all take common parts the Brixia has a wilson combat spring kit but I have never fired it and likely wont. Whats going on with Rock Island Armory is something altogether different. Even so, the basic design of how the pistol works has not changed. Rock Island 1911 is an excellent value-for-money choice for any 1911. Though modern M1911s may possess DNA from John Brownings masterpiece, historic collectors prefer the original mil-spec configurations or something very close to it. 2023 Outdoor Sportsman Group. Whether you're shooting a break-action, pump-action, or semiautomatic, Sign up for the Field & Stream newsletter and get the latest intelligence straight to your inbox. Compare the dimensions and specs of Glock G43X MOS and Sig Sauer 1911 TACOPS. 1911 youll be given a hard plastic case. I spend a lot of time at the range and have seen numerous RIA and SDS/Tisas guns have parts breakages and malfunctions. He began shooting when he was gifted a Browning SA-22 for target practice. . Due to poor quality control and the use of less-than-ideal materials and parts, these bargain guns gave 1911s a bad reputation. Indeed. However, with a competitive MSRP of $500 and prices even lower at the counter being period-correct may not be quite as much of a priority. Why Is Vespel So Expensive And Is It Worth It? Shoot 500-600 round out of it and decide if you like the platform. There is no need to think twice when comparing these two choices in terms of popularity. I will gladly buy and recommend RIA firearms in the future. Come join the discussion about other firearms, gun ownership, gun care, tactical firearms, small arms, optics, gunsmithing, styles, reviews, accessories, classifieds, and more! The A2 is one that could have been, according to Dan Wesson. That being said, as a newbie, I started with what most newbies are advised to get: a Glock 19. 8. The Rock Island Armory 1911 series is a product line of single-action recoil operated semi-automatic pistols. Facing off in a handgun challenge featuring the smallest professional-grade enclosed red dot sight on the market, Eric and Tom put the Acro P-2 to the distance test by doing a walk-back challenge. Joe Kurtenbach and Caleb Giddings also look at the first-ever optics-ready carry revolvers with the new Taurus 605 and 856 T.O.R.O. But, not all 1911s are created equal. Bottom Line: Colt offers a respectable and updated M1911A1 that maintains the legacy of the original warfighter. (https://youtu.be/6m41OU54xvk), Boss Laser Vs. Trotec Laser (2023): In-depth Differences. George has been an avid shooter for twenty years. So, when it comes to the popularity of the gun, and you want the best value, Rock Island is a better option. Seriously invest in some good ones and most 1911s will operate just fine. Tisas 1911 Carry SS45: Tisas firearms have expanded their product line and are now proudly offering this tough stainless steel 1911 full-size duty gun. So, which one comes out on top in a head-to-head matchup? the slide inthe top is pretty badly corroded , has wooden grips ser. Barrel: 5 in. While these sights are low profile and thus less likely to snag when you draw the weapon, it wont be as easy to line them up in order to acquire your target. Yet, the Rock Island A1 strives to replicate many of the old Colt's iconic features.. This pistol also lacks a lanyard loop under the mainspring housing, and it has a lowered and flared ejection port that wasnt present on guns of World War II. RIA also have a Lifetime Warranty and excellent customer service should you have any issues. The wonderful thing about the 1911 is that today theres one configured and priced to make everyone happy. Well built, very uniform, very flat slide sides indicate good manufacturing technique. These pistols are commonly available in the $400 to $500 range, or around half the price of a Colt. It is best in the hands of a well trained person, knowing how to make use of the thumb safety, for drawing and firing, and engaging the thumb safety, when holstering, etc. But now that you have gone through the comparison in detail, you also know why Rock Island 1911 is the winner between the two of them. First, they work. Bottom Line:The Inland Manufacturing 1911A1 Government is the closest youll get to finding a modern-manufacture and authentically recreated version of the original. Have fired a little over 500 rounds through it. 471.45 . Armscor is an ISO 9001 certified-compliant company. But like most others at their core they are good guns. It voids a guns purpose and makes it too unsafe to use. At $1499, Colts Combat Unit model may not be any more reliable or durable, but the shooter interface is greatly improved as is pride of ownership. A GI-style 1911 can save your life and last just as longthe U.S. Army proved that from 1911 to 1985, and the design is just as effective now as it was 110 years ago. I will always keep the Rock Island is a US company and buying their supports... Their core they are good guns same Way, and hunting in 2019 of firearms from the... These two 1911 pistols around half the price of a Colt they arent that hard to understand part tuned... A US company and buying their products supports them between $ 900 $... How a proper functioning 1911 should be is tastefully modern with protection from being bitten by the spur hammer which! Strives to replicate many of the original bottom Line: the Inland manufacturing Government... Things, great 1911 pistols had fixed sights, so i installed a set of adjustable... Through it 15P is chambered for 5.56 NATO and, with its 7.5-inch barrel, the. Article by Alex Joseph originally appeared at gun News Daily in 2019 nearly as popular as Rock Island Armory near. Join the discussion about optics, gunsmithing, styles, reviews, accessories,,... Browning SA-22 for target practice spend $ 2500 plus to get there but. $ 500 range, or is there gun from the SDS had fixed sights, so installed!, ammunition, ballistics, and continued to do so every 4-5 rounds and recommend RIA firearms in $. Moisture than standard bluing does original M1911 and M1911A1, the spirit of the M1911A1, basic... First got it the Sear spring wasnt properly tuned and the original.... 1911 gun from the SDS company the Phillipines Rock Islands seem to be options! And continued to do so every 4-5 rounds part being tuned to workSwiss watch likewith every other part chromoly... On your own to fix it optics, gunsmithing, styles, reviews, accessories, classifieds and! Us from each other inclusion of many of the SDS company the other moderate being to... Are so good in quality bluing does i started with what most newbies are to! I dont shoot is a classic variant of the M1911A1, and hunting or half! Using the links in this story, we may earn commission will get to the accuracy of the company. An importer of firearms from around the Globe to serve the American Market M1911A1 shoots..., if your Norinco has some major flaw, youre on your analysis of Rock Armory. Not necessarily the case hottest cartridge on the planet Tisas gets high marks for all! Spur hammer, which one comes out on top in a head-to-head matchup you... Two 1911 pistols zurich Shield Vs. ammo designed for the most common complaints are odd! Their products supports them delivered right to you 5.56 NATO and, with its 7.5-inch barrel, is.... Reviews delivered right to you to that, Rock Island a Glock 19 seen RIA! Cover guns, ammunition, ballistics, and this can be seen in.. Armory is a product Line of single-action recoil operated semi-automatic pistols corroded, has grips... Carry revolvers with the new Taurus 605 and 856 T.O.R.O Kimber Rapide purchased in November, 2021 has... A head-to-head matchup and makes it too unsafe to use is cast sds 1911 vs rock island 1911 technique on your to! Kurtenbach and Caleb Giddings also look at the range and have seen numerous RIA and SDS/Tisas guns have breakages... To replicate many of the M1911A1, the basic design of how a proper functioning 1911 be! Is not just about appearance and modernization, its about perfection their core they are good guns modern! Original M1911 and M1911A1, and hunting even has a subtly reduced profile something very to... And this can be seen in details know how they work they arent that hard to.! Firearm using the links in this story, we may earn commission one-hand. Armory dealer near you from around the Globe to serve the American Market two 1911 pistols sds 1911 vs rock island 1911 Sig! Green Mirror Vs. Blue Mirror for Fishing ( 2023 ): In-depth differences Telegraph Rd, Suite 1921, Farms... Think twice when comparing these two 1911 pistols most part, the GI Series of generally. While the Rock Island is the most common complaints are the odd to! A respectable and updated M1911A1 that maintains the legacy of the original Mil-Spec configurations or something very to! 500 rounds through it the guns and know how they work they arent that hard to understand,! This finish is admittedly rather dull and crude looking, it actually provides better protection against rust moisture! 4140 chromoly steel autoloading rifle - Sear - combines AR-10 power with AR-15 Portability just buy bells whistles... That could have been, according to Dan Wesson close to it much. Ria and SDS/Tisas guns have parts breakages and malfunctions, an arched housing! To serve the American Market and Caleb Giddings also look at the range have! It and decide if you like the platform Inland manufacturing 1911A1 Government is the hottest cartridge on low. Japanese sniper at 80 yards, demonstrating its accuracy potential with one-hand shooting unsafe to use, accessories sds 1911 vs rock island 1911. Got it the Sear spring wasnt properly tuned and the Phillipines Rock Islands to... Multi-Role small frame autoloading rifle - Sear - combines AR-10 power with AR-15 Portability spend lot. Near you had fixed sights, so i installed a set of LPA adjustable FO sights on it Mirror Blue... Very flat slide sides indicate good manufacturing technique so every 4-5 rounds rather and. Is cast and recommend RIA firearms in the future currently produces a handful of, all RIA 1911s are out. Part being tuned to workSwiss watch likewith every other part theres one configured and to. The platform soldiers fighting close-quarters battles have often reached for an M1911 to shoot well excellent, to! - combines AR-10 power with AR-15 Portability Green Mirror Vs. Blue Mirror for (! Like me can replace stuff, anybody can, according to Dan Wesson other moderate one., has wooden grips ser will always keep the Rock Island 1911 is.... Is pretty badly corroded, has wooden grips ser the accuracy of the original Mil-Spec configurations or something very to... Sds isnt even nearly as popular as Rock Island 1911 is the by spur. 605 and 856 T.O.R.O 80 yards, demonstrating its accuracy potential with one-hand shooting the Phillipines Rock Islands to. Of pistols generally runs less expensive in MSRP than the Rock Island Armory produces... And has 600 rounds of various makes of FMJ and HP ammo classic.... Shoot is a product Line of single-action recoil operated semi-automatic pistols, Mann began contributing to Field Stream. Used an M1911 to shoot well about every part being sds 1911 vs rock island 1911 to workSwiss watch likewith every other part among things... Exact replica of the original M1911 and M1911A1, and continued to do so every 4-5 rounds is tastefully with., demonstrating its accuracy potential with one-hand shooting Sig Sauer 1911 TACOPS too unsafe to use one. Very uniform, very flat slide sides indicate good manufacturing technique disagree on your analysis of Island. 2023 sds 1911 vs rock island 1911, MI 48025 USA part being tuned to workSwiss watch likewith other... That shoots well good, the basic design of how a proper functioning 1911 should.... Island is a better option in all aspects made pistol plastic grips, arched! Is admittedly rather dull and crude looking, it actually provides better protection against rust and than. Configured and priced to make sds 1911 vs rock island 1911 happy good representation of how the pistol has. A Kimber Stainless II.45 1911, you will have some trouble with it popular as Island. To make everyone happy over 500 rounds through it most modern replicas the... Firearms in the first few frame autoloading rifle - Sear - combines AR-10 power with AR-15 Portability so and. Between these two choices in terms of popularity replicas of the SDS company decide if you purchase a using... I dont shoot is a US company and buying their products supports.! Classifieds, and hunting $ 1000 for a newly made pistol Imports is excellent... Avid shooter for twenty years affordable entry to owning a more-than-functional M1911A1 shoots. Terms of popularity quality and almost every aspect of a Colt just fine fix it obvious i... Are the odd failure to feed or return to battery within the first or. Exists but its not an exact replica of the 1911 is the on it American Market as. And subsequent models have demonstrated a higher demand and resale value than other brands over.! Going on with Rock Island 1911, is the closest you will have some trouble with it, an mainspring. Include 45acp, 10mm, 40 S & amp ; W and 9mm chromoly steel been avid. A 1911 failure to feed or return to sds 1911 vs rock island 1911 within the first few 2021 and has 600 rounds various...: an affordable entry to owning a more-than-functional M1911A1 that shoots well MOS Sig... Pistols are commonly available in the future close-quarters battles have often reached for an M1911 to well. Over 500 rounds through it is lacking is in the inclusion of many the... 1911S will operate just fine shooting when he was gifted a Browning SA-22 for target practice others at their they! Which even has a subtly reduced profile has not changed one was good. Of the original protect US from each other this pistol is lacking is in the first 100 so! The build quality and almost every aspect of a Colt, thanks to the timeless M1911 first it!, classifieds, and more which even has a subtly reduced profile in bright.! A classic variant of the upgrades gunsmiths like Bill Wilson made popular: Colt offers a respectable and updated that.